Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall – What’s Happening

Today’s topic: Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall!

The Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall was a sensitization alert caused by undeclared allergens in its popular pint flavors. Mid-2025 saw a voluntary ice cream food recall by Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery, a cottage ice cream producer. This happened due to the potential presence of undeclared soy and wheat allergens in the ice cream product.

Undeclared food allergens can pose a significant risk of harm for those with known sensitivities. There is a Class II risk of adverse health consequences from the ingestion of the said batches of this ice cream.

It is essential that you know all about the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall. Luckily, in this article, we will tell you all about it. In brief, we will discuss:

• Undeclared Allergens: We will talk about the undeclared soy or wheat present in the disputed batches of ice cream.
• Risk Level: We discuss how this is classified as a Class II risk and the temporary medical issues people who consume the disputed product may experience.
• Affected Flavors: We discuss the eight flavor varieties of pint-sized ice cream included in the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall.
• Consumer Action: Lastly, we discuss whether you should stop consuming the product and whether it is being recalled or offered a refund.

What Was The Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall – Product Details And Recall Extent

Consumers, check your freezers now. The Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall affects pints of ice cream distributed in various states.

Which Ice Cream Flavors/Packaging Are Affected?

The recall is for the following eight pint flavors of ice cream (473 ml). The items have been packed in paper cups and paper lids. The products that have been recalled are:

• Avalanche
• Cacao
• Cookie Dough
• Cookies and Cream
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• Cacao Brownie Bites
• Strawberry-Chocolate

Critical Point

Expiration dates consist of all expirations. (Format: MM/DD/YY found on the bottom of the package) for the specified varieties listed above. There is no need for a lot number. If it matches the variety that you want, then this specific variety is a part of the recall.

“July 20th, 2025:

Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery LLC has issued a voluntary recall of several ice cream products due to undeclared allergens, specifically soy and wheat. The products were distributed to six retailers in Indiana, Michigan, and Ohio in the United States.”

– Source: IWasPoisoned.com

Where Ice Cream Was Distributed

The Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall parent company is based in the state of Ohio, in the city of Wauseon. The ice cream that is being recalled is sold in pints and is destined for six retail outlets. The retail outlets are spread over three different states:

• Ohio
• Indiana (Fort Wayne)
• Michigan (Hudson)

If you purchased this type of ice cream in the region, your product is affected in the recent Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall. The products have also been withdrawn from the shelf.

The company issued a press statement concerning the voluntary recall in mid-June of 2025. Later on, the FDA termed this a Class II health hazard. 

“Food allergies and other types of food hypersensitivities affect millions of Americans and their families. Food allergies occur when the body’s immune system reacts to certain proteins in food,” according to the reports of the FDA on Food Allergies.

This indicates that the product could cause a temporary health condition due to ingestion, with conditions like severe vomiting and breathing difficulties for a person with known sensitivity.

Why The Recall – Undeclared Allergens (Soy & Wheat)

The problem that has brought about the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall is la ack of labeling. This is due to the failure of the manufacturers to include the ingredients derived from soy and/or wheat in the statement ‘Contains’ in the label.

“For allergic people, such labeling deficiencies can have serious health consequences – from severe intolerance reactions to life-threatening situations,” explains Friedel Cramer, President of the Federal Office of Consumer Protection and Food Safety (BVL). “It is therefore all the more important that consumers can use the lebensmittelwarnung.de app to filter with just a few clicks which products stand out due to unlabeled allergens and should be recalled.”

– Source: Lack of labeling can be life-threatening

What Went Wrong- Labeling Error & Accountability

This kind of misidentification case within the food industry can be traced back to an issue regarding the quality of the products during their manufacturing. Some general reasons leading to an unlabeled allergen, like in the case of the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery, could include.

Ingredient Mix-Up

A supplier accidentally delivered a component consisting of soy/wheat to a certain ingredient.

Cross-Contact

The products were processed in equipment that was also used for a flavor containing an allergen. Next, this equipment was not sufficiently cleaned, resulting in cross-contact contamination.

Packaging Error

The actual formula of the product had been prepared properly but the package or label on the final product had issues.

This is what Robopac USA had to say in their article Common Packaging Errors and How To Avoid Them: 

“For food products, the absence of nutritional information can be a regulatory violation. For items that are fragile or hazardous, missing warning labels can lead to mishandling, product damage, and other costly mistakes. Clear and comprehensive product information is vital for ensuring safe, responsible handling throughout the supply chain.”

Food Allergens – FDA

Food regulation also requires that “the nine major Food Allergens must be labeled on food packaging by the food manufacturer if the Food Allergens are present in the food. This is an important provision that protects the consumer.

Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall – Food Issues

Issues associated with the risks under the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall are a concern for people with sensitivities.

Soy Allergy

Symptoms range from mild to life-threatening, and soy extracts hiding in foods are serious considerations.

Wheat Allergy

In this allergy, the immune system is allergic to proteins present in wheat. The symptoms of this allergy vary from skin conditions to respiratory complications.

Note: Persons affected by Celiac Disease, as well as those affected by autoimmune conditions triggered by gluten in wheat, are also at risk of intestinal damage. They cannot use this product either. Even a little amount can be dangerous too.

Read Also: Herbalife Relaxation Tea Recall: Safety Risks And Future Course

Steps To Be Taken Now – Immediate Actions

It is now left to the consumers to take urgent measures. Here are some of the steps that you can take after the news of the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall:

Do Not Consume

Do not consume any pint-sized ice cream flavors contained within the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall.

Check Your Freezer

Now, compare your name for the flavors and the name for the pint size of your Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery ice cream with this list.

Select Disposal Or Refund

It must be wrapped correctly and then placed in that closed trash can so that no one else, whether children or pets, accidentally ingests it and gets injured.

Refund Or Return For Refund

It is possible to return the ice cream to the vendor where you bought it for a full refund. As a general rule, there is no need to show a receipt when returning ice cream for a refund due to a recall.

Reaching Out To The Company

For any other queries, concerns, or a refund, one can reach out to the creamery company directly at 419-583-7124.

Post Consummation Surveillance

If you or members of your family have consumed the recalled food product, you must monitor it for signs of an allergy and act accordingly.

Watch Out For These Symptoms

• Numbness around the mouth area,
• hives,
• vomiting, and
• pain in the lower abdomen.
• Obtain Medical Care

In all cases, seek immediate care should you observe swelling, difficulty breathing, or dizziness. Report Adverse Reactions: It is also expected of you to report any drug-related adverse reaction or sickness to the FDA MedWatch reporting system.

The Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall highlights a crucial point for small-scale food processors. Small-scale food manufacturers are viewed as inherently cleaner or safer simply because of their size.

Maybe the small-scale food processor or creamery does not need a multi-level system of separating allergens like in the bigger industrial food processors.

The failure to specifically state the possible absence of soy and wheat from the product highlights weaknesses in the company’s allergen control processes. All food manufacturers must therefore closely follow U.S. food allergen labeling laws.

Consumer Best Practices

It is a healthy reminder for those with food allergies to read the Label Each and Every Time. Do not neglect a food if you recognize it, particularly if a manufacturer releases a variety of flavors with many add-ins such as cookies, doughnuts, and brownie bits.

Cross-Contact

When purchasing non-processed foods from a local grocery store, ask the staff specifically about cross-contact and allergy practices.

Stay Informed

To receive notifications by email, as in the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall alert system today, sign up with the FDA alert and alert systems made possible by your State Department of Agriculture.

Read Also: Feel Good Foods Macaroni Bites Recall – Act Immediately, Ensure Safety!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):

There are always questions for consumers regarding large-scale alerts on foods, such as those in the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall Announcement Online today. These questions and their answers are explored below.