RaDonda Vaught: Punishing Honest Medical Mistakes Is Not A Solution

Do you consider that punishing a healthcare professional is justified because their honest mistake took someone’s life? On one hand, it is true that there is no second chance for a mistake in the healthcare sector, especially when it is a life that hangs in the balance!

But it is also important to remember that healthcare professionals are also humans who are under tremendous pressure to save lives. excessive work pressure, sleep schedule, wrong guidance, mismanagement of other healthcare staff and there are several other issues that influence their actions.

Let us go through the RaDonda Vaught case in detail so that you get a perspective, learn significant lessons regarding the treatment of healthcare professionals and raise awareness!

What Happened?

Case in point, a former Tennessee nurse, RaDonda Vaught, was sentenced to probation for three years on 13 May 2022. The poor medical professional made a fatal professional medication error on one of her patients, Charlene Murphey, aged 75, leading to her death.

The incident happened in 2017 when the nurse administered a lethal dose of a paralytic drug accidentally. The actual medication that needed to be administered was a sedative. The RaDonda Vaught Case begs to ask a very important question? Don’t medical professionals consider honest mistakes, however severe?

When speaking to the family directly for the first time since the case began, a tearful Vaught apologized to them for her mistake, saying she would be forever haunted by her role in her patient’s untimely death.

Vaught looked at a maximum of twelve years in prison after the jury found her guilty of two felonies on March 25, 2022. 

Genuine Medical Mistakes and Prevention

When healthcare professionals genuinely make mistakes in their profession, punishing them might not be an effective step towards growth. When evaluating the RaDonda Vaught case, you will realize that there was an error.

The nurse administered the wrong medication to the patient and did not follow through and monitor the patient after the medication was administered. The outcome was severe, the death of the patient, Murphey, leading to criminal charges being levied against Vaught.

The charges were severe, destroying the career of the nurse, apart from her feeling guilty. Apart from criminally negligent homicide, she was also charged with impaired adult abuse, which the Jury found the nurse guilty on both charges on 25th March 2022.

The RaDonda Vaught case actually arose a lot of controversy but also taught several lessons and the impact on the overall healthcare profession.

The question arises here, should medical and healthcare professionals report their errors or cover it up? It is important for the healthcare sector to have a culture of open communication!

Criminal Prosecution Rare in Medical Malpractice

Criminal prosecution is quite rare for medical malpractice, and Vaught’s case is one of the most recent cases that has attracted national attention. Among the huge section of nurses, there is a mix of feelings regarding the verdict in the RaDonda Vaught case.

There are a lot who have traveled long ways to protect the verdict, and stand in solidarity for her. There are even doctors and nurses who consider this verdict as a wrong precedent for other practitioners in healthcare.

Other healthcare providers and practitioners will reconsider reporting errors or near misses because they will be afraid of prosecution. There are also healthcare professionals who have left the profession in the past few years citing Vaught’s case as a worrisome future.

Healthcare professionals have risked their lives during the Corona pandemic treating and caring for patients. However, committing one mistake has led to the world and the society punishing them thus, breaking their heart from the services and practices.

Criminal Charges Not a Solution

Even with the guilty verdict, the blame for the terrible accident is still debatable. 

According to Vaught’s attorney, his client made an honest mistake and blamed the hospital’s mechanized medication system.

However, the prosecution maintained that Vaught overlooked many obvious signs that should have made her realize that she had taken the wrong medication and failed to monitor her patient closely.

“While recklessness in health care institutions can’t be overlooked, everyone must understand that accidents sometimes happen even when the healthcare provider means well,” says criminal lawyer David Benowitz. 

According to players in the healthcare industry, punishing one nurse cannot be a guarantee that the mistakes will not recur somewhere else, and Vaught is not the first healthcare provider to make errors resulting in death.

A study conducted before the COVID-19 pandemic showed that medical errors were America’s third leading cause of death. 

It’s a Bittersweet Ending

Aleece Ellison, a nurse who had traveled from Texas in support of Vaught, said she had never felt as helpless in her 14 years as a nurse when the jury found Vaught guilty.

Another nurse, Janie Reed, who had traveled from Memphis to stand in solidarity with Vaught, said she’d be considering whether to stay on the job or seek other employment, citing that the bedside had become dangerous.  

According to the nurses, criminalizing honest mistakes will affect how healthcare providers report medical errors, which many nurses feel will have a massive impact on the safety of patients. 

Luckily for Vaught, she did not get the sentence most of her supporters feared. Judge Jennifer Smith, Nashville Criminal Court, imposed the three-year probation and said she would receive judicial diversion.

This provision in the criminal justice system allows first-time offenders to have their criminal record expunged and the charges dropped after completing their probation. 

Wrapping Up!

In conclusion, we need to be aware of how healthcare professionals need to be supported when they are in a crisis. Based on the RaDonda Vaught case, systematic factors in the healthcare sector have been questioned and highlighted as a need to be addressed.

Further questions have been raised regarding how professional healthcare service providers are prosecuted criminally due to their medical errors, sometimes genuine errors. Instead, they need a supportive environment for both doctors and nurses.

Now that you have gone through this case, what do you think of the matter? Do you think it is necessary for having a communication platform for everyone to share their perspective and get second chances?

Read More:

• How to Gather Strong Medical Evidence for a Disability Claim
• Hire an Experienced NJ Car Accident Lawyer & Win Your Case
• Bet You Didn’t Know About These 5 Myths on Personal Injury Law